+263 86 12 00 8884
770 Fern Road, Hatfield, Harare, ZW
M&J Consultants
M&J Consultants
Tax
  • Tax Legislation
  • Tax Operations
  • Tax Services
  • Tax Technology Consulting
Management Consulting
  • Strategic Advisory
  • Internal Audits & Controls
  • Mergers & Acquisitions
  • Market Expansion
Enterprise Resource Planning
  • Odoo ERP Zimbabwe
  • Palladium Accounting
Business Systems
  • Sage Pastel
  • Zoho Books
  • Quickbooks
Payroll
  • Odoo Payroll
Content
  • Insights
  • Case Studies
  • Events & Webinars
Tools
  • PAYE Calculator
  • VAT Calculator
  • VAT Checklist
  • Compliance Calendar 2026
  • Zimbabwe Investment Guide
About Us Get In Touch
[email protected] | +263 86 12 00 8884
Get In Touch
business strategy

Shareholder Deadlock in Profitable Zimbabwe Companies

By M&J Consultants • 12 min read
Shareholder Deadlock in Profitable Zimbabwe Companies

M&J Consultants — Corporate Governance and Business Advisory Team

Key takeaway

Profitability does not prevent deadlock. Align voting rules, reserved matters and continuity arrangements, then agree mediation and a funded exit mechanism before disagreement threatens the business.

A profitable business can still stop moving. Two shareholders may agree on customers, revenue and product quality, yet disagree completely on whether to reinvest cash, declare dividends or appoint a new director.

Shareholder deadlock becomes commercially dangerous when a 50:50 ownership structure gives each owner the power to block decisions. In Zimbabwe, the Companies and Other Business Entities Act [Chapter 24:31], known as the COBE Act, provides court remedies in serious cases. Clear voting and exit terms give shareholders a better way to protect enterprise value before a disagreement reaches court.

We see the central governance question early in any company registration or shareholder advisory instruction: what happens when the people with equal authority no longer agree? A company can trade profitably while its board cannot approve a budget, sign off a major transaction or appoint a successor director.

Why profitable companies still reach deadlock

Profit does not resolve a governance dispute. It can intensify one because shareholders must decide who receives cash, who controls its deployment and what level of risk the company should accept.

A shareholder may want distributions after several profitable years. Another may want to retain earnings for stock, property, technology or regional expansion. Neither position is inherently wrong, but equal voting rights without a resolution process can turn a commercial difference into paralysis.

Under section 62 of the COBE Act, a member may seek court relief when directors, managers or members are deadlocked and irreparable business injury is likely, or when the business can no longer operate to the members’ advantage. The issue is therefore not whether the company has money in the bank. The issue is whether the company can make and implement decisions.

The Registrar of Companies and Other Business Entities administers the COBE Act through the Companies Office. Founders should address deadlock at the formation stage, when they complete company registration and still have alignment on the business plan.

Worked example: the dividend dispute

Consider a profitable Harare distributor owned equally by two shareholders, both directors. One wants to reinvest earnings in stock and delivery capacity; the other seeks a dividend and refuses the proposed annual budget. Neither has the votes or agreed procedure to resolve the stalemate.

The company has no casting vote, mediation provision or agreed exit clause. Routine decisions stall, even though customers continue to place orders and the company remains profitable. A court application could disrupt the business and may result in a fair-value buyout, governance intervention or liquidation.

A well-drafted shareholders’ agreement could require a defined negotiation window followed by independent mediation and, if needed, a funded buy-sell process. The timetable should be negotiated by the parties; an illustrative response period is not a statutory deadline. Funding, valuation and transfer mechanics matter as much as the right to exit.

Step 1: Test whether your voting rules create a veto

Start with the memorandum, articles and shareholders’ agreement. These documents must work together. A shareholders’ agreement may form part of a company’s internal rules under the COBE Act, but it should remain consistent with the memorandum and articles.

The mistake we see most often is placing detailed voting and exit provisions only in a private shareholders’ agreement. If the memorandum or articles say something different, the inconsistency creates uncertainty at precisely the moment shareholders need a clear answer.

Section 170 of the COBE Act generally sets the meeting quorum at a majority of votes entitled to vote, unless the memorandum provides otherwise within the statutory limits. It also provides for reconvened meetings with a different default quorum. Read the full section alongside the company’s memorandum before concluding that absence creates a permanent veto.

For a 50:50 company, these rules can create a practical veto. If one owner does not attend and quorum fails, the meeting cannot proceed. If both attend but disagree, neither can secure the majority required for an ordinary decision.

A special resolution ordinarily needs support from at least 75% of votes represented at a properly convened meeting, with the statutory notice and attendance requirements. Section 175 should be read alongside the company’s own documents for the precise process.

Special resolutions apply to matters such as amendments to the memorandum, mergers, major transactions and dissolution. A 50:50 shareholder cannot force these outcomes alone, which is why founders should not assume equal ownership automatically creates balance.

Board voting needs separate attention

Shareholders often focus on share voting and ignore the board. That leaves a gap because daily decisions usually sit with directors, not shareholders.

The COBE Act model articles allow a board chairperson to hold a casting vote, subject to the company’s articles. Do not assume the chair has one. Read the adopted articles and confirm whether the casting vote applies to every board decision or excludes particular matters.

A casting vote may solve routine operational stalemates, but it can create a control imbalance if one founder can use it on matters that affect ownership value. We generally advise clients to reserve fundamental decisions for shareholder approval rather than leave them to a chairperson’s casting vote.

Step 2: Define reserved matters before conflict starts

Reserved matters are decisions that require a higher approval threshold than ordinary management decisions. They should appear clearly in the memorandum, articles and shareholders’ agreement where appropriate.

For a company with two equal owners, the list should cover matters that alter capital, control or long-term risk. Examples include issuing new shares, borrowing above an agreed amount, selling material assets, changing the dividend policy, approving a merger and appointing or removing directors.

The judgement is not how many matters appear on the reserved list. Requiring unanimous approval for routine procurement can freeze the company; allowing one director to commit the company to material debt can create unacceptable risk. Agree decision categories and approval limits proportionate to the actual business.

Set financial thresholds that reflect the company’s actual scale. Review them annually with the budget, because a threshold suitable for a start-up can become irrelevant after growth.

Worked example: the expanding retailer

Take an owner-managed Zimbabwean retailer with two equal shareholders. One proposes a second branch and a multi-year lease; the other wants the company to strengthen liquidity and fulfil existing commitments first. Their disagreement is about risk appetite, not necessarily bad faith.

If every operational item needs unanimous agreement, procurement and staffing may stall. If a material lease can be signed without adequate approval, shareholders may face commitments they did not authorise. Reserve major expansion and long-term obligations while allowing routine operations under an approved budget.

The shareholders should also specify what they would do differently if the budget fails. They could require a revised budget within a defined period, then refer only the disputed items to mediation rather than freezing the whole business.

Step 3: Build an escalation path that preserves the business

A deadlock clause should not begin with litigation. Court proceedings can protect rights, but they often consume management time, expose internal disagreement and strain relationships with lenders, suppliers and employees.

Set out the stages in order. A practical process may require the directors to meet within a stated number of business days, followed by a meeting of shareholders, then mediation with an agreed independent mediator.

The clause should also state which decisions can continue while the dispute remains unresolved. Payroll, tax filings, customer deliveries and obligations under existing contracts should not automatically stop because shareholders disagree on a growth project.

Mediation has value because it tests whether the dispute concerns principle, price or communication. A shareholder who rejects a dividend may accept a defined distribution policy. A shareholder who opposes expansion may accept it if the business limits debt and agrees a valuation mechanism.

If mediation fails, the parties need a binding exit route. Do not rely on statutory appraisal rights as an all-purpose solution. Under the COBE Act, appraisal rights are narrow and apply to specified matters such as certain variations of class rights and mergers, subject to a statutory objection and demand process.

Step 4: Agree an exit mechanism that can actually close

A buy-sell clause gives shareholders a private method to separate when continued joint ownership no longer serves the enterprise. The clause should identify the trigger, valuation method, purchaser, payment terms and transfer procedure.

A right of first refusal can work where one shareholder receives a genuine third-party offer. It gives the other shareholder a chance to buy on the same terms, which protects the company from an unwanted new owner.

Put and call options can work where shareholders want defined rights to sell or buy after stated events. A Russian roulette or Texas shoot-out clause can also resolve a 50:50 deadlock, but it requires careful drafting because a shareholder with greater access to funding may gain an advantage.

The valuation provisions deserve more attention than the label attached to the clause. State the valuation date, who appoints the independent valuer, the standard of value, the information the valuer may inspect and who bears the cost.

Also state how the buyer funds the transaction. If the price is payable over time, require payment security and define what happens if the buyer defaults. Without these details, the parties can win an argument about exit and still fail to complete the transfer.

If your turnover and cash reserves cannot support a funded buyout, do not adopt a complex shoot-out mechanism simply because it appears in a template. Use a valuation process and payment structure that the company and shareholders can realistically honour.

Step 5: Know when court relief becomes necessary

Section 62 of the COBE Act gives the court broad powers where deadlock causes or threatens serious harm. Remedies can include mediation, a custodian, a forensic audit, the appointment or removal of directors, damages, dividend orders, amendments to constitutive documents, a fair-value purchase of shares or liquidation.

This breadth matters because liquidation is not the automatic first answer. The court can preserve a viable enterprise through a governance remedy or buyout where that better serves the circumstances.

The Insolvency Act also provides a last-resort liquidation route where directors are deadlocked, members cannot break the deadlock and the company suffers actual or likely irreparable injury, or cannot continue for the members’ advantage. Another ground concerns shareholder voting deadlock lasting at least two financial years over the election of successor directors.

Liquidation is a serious and technical remedy that must follow the applicable Insolvency Act and court procedures. An applicant should obtain Zimbabwean legal advice on standing, procedural papers, creditor implications and the suitability of any less destructive remedy before proceedings begin.

Documents to review this quarter

For established companies, we recommend a focused governance review rather than waiting for a dispute. Put the memorandum, articles, shareholders’ agreement, board resolutions and current cap table on the same table.

Ask whether they answer these questions:

  • Which decisions require board approval, ordinary shareholder approval or a special resolution?

  • Does the board chair have a casting vote under the articles, and should that vote apply to the matter in question?

  • What happens if a meeting lacks quorum or a vote fails?

  • Which matters are reserved, and are their financial thresholds still appropriate?

  • How do shareholders appoint an independent valuer, fund a buyout and transfer shares?

  • Do the memorandum and articles align with the shareholders’ agreement?

This review also supports stronger corporate governance for lenders, investors and prospective buyers. A buyer undertaking due diligence will look beyond profitability and ask whether control rights, board authority and exit obligations are documented coherently.

A practical decision-rights check

  • Check the memorandum, articles and shareholders’ agreement for quorum and voting inconsistencies.

  • Define which strategic decisions are reserved to shareholders and which can continue through management.

  • Provide mediation, valuation and a realistically funded exit path before a dispute arises.

  • Assign a continuity protocol for payroll, tax, customer service and existing contracts during a deadlock.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is shareholder deadlock illegal in Zimbabwe?

No. Deadlock is not illegal by itself. It becomes legally significant when it causes likely irreparable business injury or means the business can no longer operate to the members’ advantage under section 62 of the COBE Act.

Can one 50% shareholder force a dividend?

Usually not without the required approval under the company’s documents and applicable voting rules. A 50:50 split often means either shareholder can block a dividend decision, which is why a dividend policy and deadlock process matter.

Can a chairperson break a board deadlock?

Possibly, if the company’s articles give the chairperson a casting vote. The COBE Act model articles allow this subject to the articles, so shareholders should check the actual adopted document before relying on it.

Can a shareholder force the other to sell?

Not as a general rule. A shareholder may have rights under an agreed buy-sell clause, a put or call option, or a court order in appropriate circumstances. Statutory appraisal rights do not provide a general exit route for routine shareholder deadlock.

A profitable company deserves governance arrangements that protect its value when personal or strategic alignment changes. Speak With Our Team to review your shareholders’ agreement, voting provisions and exit terms before a disagreement starts deciding the future of the business.

This article provides general information and does not replace legal or tax advice based on the company’s documents and circumstances.

Share this article:

About the Author

M&J Consultants

Expert insights from the M&J Consultants team.

Free consultation

Need expert guidance?

Tell us about your business and one of our consultants will get back to you within one working day.

No spam. We only use your details to respond to this inquiry.

Something went wrong. Please try again or contact us directly.

Thanks, we've got it.

A consultant will reach out within one working day.

Prefer to talk now? Contact page

Related Articles

10 Lucrative Investment Opportunities in Zimbabwe for 2025
business strategy | M&J Consultants

10 Lucrative Investment Opportunities in Zimbabwe for 2025

Read Article
15 Low-Cost Small Business Ideas You Can Start in Zimbabwe with Limited Capital
business strategy | M&J Consultants

15 Low-Cost Small Business Ideas You Can Start in Zimbabwe with Limited Capital

Read Article
2026 ZIMRA Compliance Calendar for Zimbabwe Companies
business strategy | M&J Consultants

2026 ZIMRA Compliance Calendar for Zimbabwe Companies

Read Article

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get the latest insights delivered to your inbox.

M&J Consultants

Building Timeless Businesses

Africa's Premier Business Consultancy.

Services

  • Tax
  • Management Consulting
  • Digital Transformation

Industries

  • Agriculture
  • Manufacturing
  • Energy
  • Education

Company

  • About Us
  • Case Studies
  • Insights
  • Contact

Free Tools

  • PAYE Calculator
  • VAT Calculator
  • VAT Readiness Checklist
  • Compliance Calendar 2026
  • Zimbabwe Investment Guide

Contact

[email protected]

+263 86 12 00 8884

+263 78 098 2877 (WhatsApp)

770 Fern Road, Hatfield, Harare

© 2026 M&J Consultants. All rights reserved.